A Project Genesis website

JewishAnswers.org

Ask the Rabbi: answers from Project Genesis rabbis

,

Abraham not Protesting the Akedah

Question

Why didn’t Abraham protest when he was told to sacrifice Isaac, when he did protest about the destruction of possible righteous people in Sodom?

Answer

1) For a (relatively) disinterested person to protest against possible injustice is one thing; to disobey or protest a direct Divine order is quite another thing. 2) In the Talmud Yerushalmi (Taanis 2:4) and in many Midrashim, Abraham is quoted as saying to G-d (afterwards) that he could have protested when he was told to offer Isaac as a sacrifice, since G-d had promised him descendants through Isaac, but he suppressed his feelings and didn’t protest. 3) Many commentators and Midrashim point out that G-d didn’t explicitly tell Abraham to sacrifice Isaac, but only to “raise him up” as an offering. True, Abraham brought wood, fire, and a knife to the mountain, but he may have believed that G-d would provide an animal to be sacrificed; indeed, this is what he told Isaac on the way up the mountain, and this is what actually happened.